Here are my answers to the four questions I ask on the first of each month:
first, what are you reading?
what do you like best about it?
what do you like least?
what's next on your list to read?
As always, I hope you'll consider your current reads on your blog and/or sharing here in the comments or on Facebook. Happy reading!
What are you reading?
Get Real: What Kind of
World Are You Buying? By Mara Rockliff. This book is about responsible buying and consumerism.
Good Calories/Bad
Calories by Gary Taubes.
What do you like best about them?
Getting Real is
very eye-opening in its discussion of where things come from. I like best that
it challenges kids to not think as consumers but as people. The book helps kids realize that they
hold enormous power in their buying power, and also that they are influenced by
the ads they see, regardless of what they think. I gave it to my 13-year-old daughter after I read it,
and told her that I didn’t agree with everything in the book. She agreed that she didn’t like
everything about it, but especially thought that she was more immune to
advertisements than others. I had
to laugh at that, and we had a good discussion about trying to remain conscious
about the lure of consumerism.
I think that’s one of the best take-away points. You are influenced by the culture
around you. Realizing it and
accepting it will help you be a savvier consumer, and overall a better
person. That’s not just true about
consumerism, but also media we consume.
If you think you can watch or read whatever is around and think it has
no effect on you, you’re wrong.
I’m not sure what I like about Good Calories/Bad Calories.
He is good and award-winning science writer, but it’s a science and
nutrition book I found hard to get through.
What do you like least about them?
Getting Real is a little,
no, a lot, on the frankly polemic side against any sort of non-local business,
whether it’s Wal-Mart, Starbucks
or McDonalds. I find those kind of attacks that shed more heat than
light, and disregard the strides these companies have made. I will admit, of course, that it’s
because of the strident protests by people like Rockliff. What I find annoying about
Rockliff’s approach is that it’s kind of an either/or, rather than a both.
For instance, I can find much more, and better quality,
organic produce, at our closest Wal-Mart than I can at our local grocery
store. I also can find that at our
local farmer’s market, which I do in the summer, but I am so grateful to have
the source of great healthful produce (and inexpensive other groceries)
year-round from Wal-Mart.
And while my kids dislike McDonald’s in general (except for the
breakfasts), I enjoy the oatmeal and the salads and enjoy having those healthful
options when traveling or needing a drive-through.
I just don’t buy the notion that all big business is bad,
just like I don’t buy the notion that big government is bad. I’m glad that there are McDonalds,
Starbucks and Wal-Marts, and I’m glad there are national parks, the military,
and lots of other things in federal government. I know both those “biggies” can improve, but Getting Real seems to think we’d be
better off without big business, instead of trying to improve them, in the same
way some more radical libertarians want to do away with the federal government. Both those are too extreme for
me.
Good Calories, Bad
Calories is frustrating because there’s essentially no conclusion, other
than the argument it makes that a low-fat, high carbohydrate diet is not good
fit for human consumption. More
troubling, I find, is Taubes apparent claim that the only way to live healthy, long and trim, is with essentially a
no-carbohydrate diet. He claims
that people who eat only meat suffer no ill effects. Some of the arguments in the book just made my head spin. So if eating only meat and
high-protein, high-fat foods is the only way to go, what do you do when it’s
your birthday? No birthday
cake? No vegetables? Strange.
Reading this gave me a kind of reverse of déjà vu from
reading The China Study several years
back, a book that makes an equally dense and impassioned, well-documented
argument that the only way to live
healthy, trim and long is through a vegan diet. I’d like to get these two authors in a room to duke it
out.
My problem with both of those nutrition exposes (not sure
how to get the accent there, I mean the noun, not the verb) is a tendency to
over-dramatize. Yes,
clearly, the low-fat, refined carbohydrate diet is not healthy, but I thought
we all know that by now. By the
same token, few people will be able to stay on either a no-carbohydrate or
completely vegan diet forever, regardless of how healthy.
Much more interesting, but only occasionally referenced, was
the notion that overweight and obese people do not necessarily overeat, but may
have a barely perceptible hormone imbalance. That would be interesting to explore or solve.
Finally, I just found it ridiculous that Taubes dismisses
exercise as a way to manage weight and stay healthy. I’m not going to even start on that.
What’s next on your
list to read?
I’ve actually just finished The Wilder Life: My
Adventures in the Lost World of Little House on the Prairie by Wendy
McClure, and I LOVED it, but I want to wait to next month to write about
it. It’s that good. Stay tuned.
I’ve also downloaded for the Kindle App some Georgette Heyer
books, written in the mid-20th century. They’re kind of romance/mystery/madcap books for people who
love Jane Austen. I learned from
Austenblog earlier this month that there was an e-book sale, so I grabbed a couple
of titles I have not yet read. Unfortunately, I have not had much free “fun
reading” time, but having these great Heyer books makes me want to find some
time.
So, what are you reading? Any books to add to my growing stacks?
I just finished Elizabeth Elliot's Passion and Purity! This was a re-read from my pre-marriage days. It was so uplifting! I'm reading a lot of chasity/virtue/purity books these days as I have a tween in this house and more to come. :)
ReplyDelete